The following serves as a response to The Star-News’ Jan. 30, 2016 article, “City’s internal investigation clears councilman of wrongdoing.”
This article addressed a human resources issue pertaining to the separation of Mr. McCann’s part-time council aide hired for only six months at the city of Chula Vista, dating back almost a year ago. The story, written by reporter Robert Moreno, took advantage of the employee confidentiality obligations our office must abide by, resulting in an article that was prejudicial rather than probative.
It would be improper, both legally and ethically, for Mr. McCann or staff to disclose to the media details pertinent to Mr. Roach’s employment and termination.
In upholding this standard of professionalism and discretion, an unbalanced article containing rampant speculation was sent to press uncontested. In publishing extended, unverifiable commentary labeled as ‘news’ — directed at individuals legally incapable of comment — The Star-News fell woefully short of the threshold for journalistic integrity set by the Society of Professional Journalists Code of Ethics. This publication must raise its journalistic standards to provide Chula Vista the quality news it so richly deserves.
While Mr. McCann is saddened by these political accusations, the likes of which regrettably plague nearly all public figures, our office remains focused on serving our constituency each and every day. Mr. McCann has engrained in his staff a respect for the apolitical nature of the Chula Vista City Council. Employees are continuously reminded to keep all political events and activities separate from their work with the city of Chula Vista. Mr. McCann has only fostered a culture of collaboration and creating positive relationships with others.
We are disappointed that Mr. Roach chose to discuss private human resources information in such a public manner, and that The Star-News willingly published these claims — ethically and legally incapable of being contested. Mr. McCann and I continue to wish Mr. Roach the very best in his future endeavors, and hope moving forward that The Star-News will rise to become a standard-bearer for journalistic integrity in Chula Vista — not sink to the level of sensationalist tabloid.
Martin is chief of staff for Councilman John McCann.
